top of page

Rethinking Video Quantity to Maximize Impact & ROI

What You’ll Gain from This Post

This post decodes the often-confusing choice between producing more videos or fewer, more impactful ones. You'll learn how to allocate your budget to maximize impact, understand the nuanced choice between more videos or fewer high-quality ones, and appreciate the value of re-assessing your strategy as you go.

By the end, you'll be equipped to transform your video marketing plan from merely acceptable to truly remarkable.

The Dilemma Most Brands Face: Quantity vs Quality in a Content-Hungry World

If you're steering the ship of a brand's marketing strategy, you likely know the tightrope you have to walk. The digital landscape is endlessly hungry for content; the more you can push out, the more digital real estate you can occupy. In many cases, more content can mean more visibility, engagement, and traction for your brand.

But—and it's a significant 'but'—the mantra that 'more is better' doesn't always hold water regarding results. While a high volume of content can grab more eyeballs, it risks diluting your central message, causing viewer fatigue, or even diminishing the overall quality of your product.

So, how do you navigate this tricky balance between quality and quantity? In this post, we're going to dive into the complex yet essential principle that should guide your decision on the number of videos to produce, whether you're considering ten videos, five, or even just one high-impact piece. Our aim? To clear the fog surrounding this age-old dilemma and provide a roadmap for a strategy that will maximize your impact and return on investment.

Rethinking "Quality": The Evolving Landscape of What Truly Matters

In today's fast-evolving digital landscape, the word "quality" isn't as straightforward as it once was. Think back to 20 years ago, when the difference between a high-quality TV and a low-quality one was night and day—a vivid display versus a blurry one. The concept of quality was far more simplistic, easily measured by the sharpness of an image or the clarity of sound.

Fast forward to today, and the lines have blurred. Place a $300 TV next to a $10,000 model, and to the untrained eye, the differences can seem almost negligible. The bar for basic "quality" has risen so high that the term now encompasses much more than just technical excellence—it's more nuanced, layered, and highly contextual.

Let's apply this notion to the realm of video production and marketing. Yes, visual quality still plays an undeniable role. You can tell within the first few seconds whether you're watching a high-budget national TV ad or a local mom-and-pop commercial. The difference is palpable, almost instinctive.

However, context changes everything. A few years ago I worked on a campaign for an LG smartphone. Interestingly, the entire commercial was shot using the phone itself. The goal was to showcase the device's capability to capture high-quality video, and guess what? The campaign was a massive hit. The DIY look of the footage didn't just work—it thrived—because it was completely aligned with the context and message of the ad.

So, what's the big takeaway here? Quality isn't a single-layered metric anymore; it's multi-dimensional. Sometimes, it's about the crispness of the visuals, the lens used, or the size of the crew. At other times, it's about the brilliance and relevance of the idea itself.

Quality isn't a single-layered metric anymore; it's multi-dimensional. Sometimes, it's about the crispness of the visuals, the lens used, or the size of the crew. At other times, it's about the brilliance and relevance of the idea itself.

To produce videos that truly resonate and are effective in their mission, you have to dial in both aspects with precision. So when you think of 'quality,' remember: it's not just about how good something looks or sounds, but also about how well it fits the story you're trying to tell and the goals you aim to achieve. And it’s important that you think of quality this way going forward, especially in this post.

When More is Actually Less: The Art of Strategic Decision-Making in Video Marketing

In the realm of video marketing, the mantra 'more is better' is often thrown around like confetti, especially when budgets are ample. However, in many cases, the truth is quite the opposite.

Contrary to popular belief, the most impactful brands aren't recklessly spending on a multitude of high-profile commercials just because they have the resources. Instead, they rigorously assess the optimal number of videos that will provide the greatest impact, and allocate their budgets accordingly. Why? Because the effectiveness of a video marketing strategy doesn't scale in a straight line with either budget or quantity.

Let's illustrate this principle with what could be called the "Super Bowl Ad Dilemma." Picture a brand splurging to run not one but two commercials during the Super Bowl, a golden window for advertisement. While it may seem logical to think that doubling the airtime equates to doubling the impact, the reality is quite different. Those two commercials would end up competing for the viewer's attention, diluting the brand's core message and, ironically, lessening the overall impact.

The smarter move is one standout commercial, supported by smaller, targeted content throughout the year. And that's exactly how big brands approach their strategies. This maximizes both impact and ROI.

So when faced with the choice of quantity versus quality, remember: often, less is more.

Practical Advice: Decision-Making on a Budget

When it comes to video marketing, it's all about effective budget allocation. Let's say you have a $60,000 budget. A common approach might be to divide it equally across four videos, each costing $15,000. However, this strategy may not offer the best return on investment or make a lasting impression on your audience.

Instead, consider creating one "spearhead" video with a $40,000 budget. This centerpiece video should be meticulously crafted to embody your brand's core message and values. Then, use the remaining $20,000 to produce 6-8 smaller, supplementary pieces of content. These can range from social media clips to behind-the-scenes footage, each enhancing and reiterating the main message of your spearhead video.

By adopting this approach, you're maximizing the compound impact of your video content while also boosting ROI. The end result? A campaign that moves beyond just being "acceptable" and ventures into the realm of the "remarkable."

Actionable Steps for Optimized Video Marketing

In the ever-evolving landscape of video marketing, understanding the balance between quality and quantity is essential for brand success. Before you finalize your video marketing plan, consider these actionable steps:

1. Consider the Target Audience

This step seems deceptively simple but is crucial. Put yourself in your target audience's shoes and envision how they will react to the video(s). Ask yourself, "If the audience doesn’t respond well to the first video, will additional videos improve or worsen the situation?" This exercise will guide you in determining whether one impactful video is more effective than several less impactful ones.

2. Consider the Distribution Plan

Review your distribution strategy, including the platforms and timelines for each video release. If the same target audience will see multiple videos in a short span, it’s usually better to produce supplementary content that supports a primary, high-impact video. Conversely, if your target audience varies or the distribution schedule is spread out, individualized videos may be the better route.

3. Weigh the Value of Variation

Lastly, assess the merits of variety in your video content. For user-generated content, like influencer reviews or testimonials, variation can amplify trust and authority. However, in cases like documentary or narrative content, too much variation can dilute the overall message as different pieces compete for attention.

The balance between quality and quantity in video marketing isn't a one-size-fits-all formula; it's a nuanced equation that varies with each brand's goals, target audience, and distribution strategy.

Yet the unfortunate reality is that many brands determine the number of videos to produce based on arbitrary factors like pre-planned release schedules, overlooking the critical influence this decision can have on the campaign's overall impact and ROI.

The unfortunate reality is that many brands determine the number of videos to produce based on arbitrary factors like pre-planned release schedules, overlooking the critical influence this decision can have on the campaign's overall impact and ROI.

Therefore, it's essential to apply the same level of thoughtful evaluation to the quantity of videos being created as you would to each video's individual production. Taking the time to carefully weigh your options using these actionable steps can be the difference between a campaign that is merely 'acceptable' and one that is truly 'remarkable.'


The art of impactful video marketing is as intricate as it is rewarding. In a digital world awash with content, the campaigns that resonate are those that wield a finely crafted, clear message. It’s important to remember that It’s not a one-size-fits-all approach; it’s about tailoring each project to maximize both impact and ROI.

Choosing the right production partner can be the pivotal difference between an acceptable campaign and a remarkable one. At Intrigue Studios, we don't just aim to collaborate on one video project; we're committed to being your long-term partner in producing better videos for brands that want bigger results.

So, if you find yourself pondering the number of videos that will make your next campaign soar, why not discuss it with a team that understands how to balance quantity and quality for maximum impact?

We invite you to reach out to Intrigue Studios today.

Together, let's create not just one successful project, but set the stage for a future filled with them. Your most impactful video marketing strategy could be just a conversation away.


Email Subscribe Button.png

Recent Posts


bottom of page